Skip to content

template_review_packet.md

Latest commit

 

History

History
96 lines (72 loc) · 2.89 KB

template_review_packet.md

File metadata and controls

96 lines (72 loc) · 2.89 KB
Raw

Review Packet Template

Planned contract; no review route is exposed before REV-13.

Routing And Lease

  • project ID:
  • ReviewQueueEntry ID:
  • ReviewLease ID:
  • canonical reviewer ActorProfile ID:
  • preferred/open routing reason:
  • lease issued/expires at:
  • conflict-of-interest attestation:
  • contributor-reviewer pair risk:
  • offline non-mutating quality sampling selected:
  • quality sampling reason:

Quality sampling cannot delay or replace the Review decision, FinalAcceptance, task effects, or contribution transaction.

Exact Submission Packet

  • task ID:
  • TaskAssignment ID:
  • Submission ID/version:
  • predecessor Submission ID:
  • admitting CheckerRun ID:
  • ReviewPacketManifest ID:
  • server-derived Submission artifact hash:
  • ART binding IDs:

Artifact bytes are available only for this exact active-lease packet. History is bounded metadata only.

Stamped Context

  • Project Guide ID/version/activation sequence:
  • source snapshot reference:
  • task-execution policy references:
  • ReviewPolicy reference:
  • RevisionPolicy reference:
  • revision preparation ID/head/digest, when applicable:
  • context outcome/direction/change summary, when applicable:

Use this stamped context. No guide rebase occurs during review.

Decision

accept | needs_revision | reject

  • immutable Review ID:
  • predecessor Review ID:
  • bounded summary:
  • reject reason, required for reject:
  • acceptance evidence, required for accept:

Immutable Findings

ReviewFinding ID Kind Area Issue/Rationale Required Change Evidence Binding ID
<uuid> blocking or advisory <area> <issue> <change or null> <uuid or null>

needs_revision requires at least one blocking finding. Reject requires its bounded reason; findings are optional when they add useful evidence.

Prior Responses And Resolutions

Prior Finding ID SubmissionFindingResponse ID Response Evidence FindingResolution Rationale
<uuid> <uuid> <binding or null> resolved, unresolved, or not_applicable <rationale>

Contribution Effects

Reviewer operation, required for every valid Review:

  • ContributionRecord ID/type completed_review:
  • source Review ID and ReviewLease ID:
  • reviewer-frozen ContributionPolicyVersion:
  • CompensationAward ID or explicit unpaid result:

Accept-only effects:

  • FinalAcceptance ID:
  • source Review ID and Submission ID:
  • accepted submitter ActorProfile ID:
  • recording reviewer ActorProfile ID:
  • TaskAssignment completed:
  • ContributionRecord ID/type accepted_submission:
  • source FinalAcceptance ID and TaskAssignment ID:
  • submitter-frozen ContributionPolicyVersion:
  • revision-prepared submitter ContributionPolicyVersion lineage, when this is a post-needs_revision attempt:
  • CompensationAward ID or explicit unpaid result:

needs_revision and reject contain no FinalAcceptance or submitter ContributionRecord.