Skip to content

Publish all 120 unseen-validation outcomes and an offline audit - #9

Closed
ianu82 wants to merge 1 commit into
review/jev-muse-evalsfrom
review/jev-muse-evidence
Closed

ianu82 wants to merge 1 commit into
review/jev-muse-evalsfrom
review/jev-muse-evidence

Conversation

@ianu82

@ianu82 ianu82 commented Sep 26, 2026 •

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor

Publishes the complete compact record of unseen-validation campaign 002, including every failure, and an audit that recalculates the outcome without API calls. Stacked on #8 (the evaluation-harness branch) so the data does not obscure the grader review; after that PR reaches staging, retarget this PR to staging.

Metric Original vanilla Frozen winner
Passed 45/60 53/60
Mean agent time 70.58s 47.37s
P50 54.30s 30.92s

Contains all 120 result/check records, 393 drained model-call records, 120 source diffs, preregistration, outage/probe records, checksums and provenance. The offline audit verifies coverage, pass flags, model identities and the acceptance decision. All upstream errors remain scored; health probes are separate. The full 109 MB screenshot/app/trace archive is retained locally, not committed, and this limit is explicit.

Validated with python3 evals/audit_results.py: accepted, 45/60 vs 53/60, exact recorded mean/P50 reproduced. Credentials and local path prefixes were checked before publication. These numbers apply to the frozen snapshot, not the later integration with current main. The invalidated prior campaign and future holdout requirements are documented.

See the recorded result and replication guide.

GitHub CI status

Linux/macOS tests, formatting and shellcheck pass. Windows record-isolation tests already fail on the unchanged main revision (TestTheNewestRecordComesFirst, TestNoRecordsIsNotAnError, TestAnUnwritableHomeIsSurvived): their HOME-only setup does not isolate Windows USERPROFILE. This PR reproduces those existing failures.

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

1 participant