fix(pm): post-stamped's quoted-stamp remedy names the route that works, not the declaration already in the fence

[huangyiirene]

Fixes #19319

What the card measured, and which half was the defect

A seat pasted a git log line into a fenced code block, declared the stamp inside the fence exactly as the contract spells a declaration, used {{NOW}} elsewhere, and was refused [mixed] with the remedy 「Declare it with {{WAS:2026-09-20T10:25:40Z}} if it is a quoted reading」 — the declaration already standing at the position the refusal was complaining about, character for character. Reproduced on this branch's base 7e1b048a1d, exit 2, before any edit.

The refusal is right; the remedy was wrong. Inside a quotation this tool renders TEXT, so a {{WAS:…}} in a fence declares nothing there and the digits stand on the board like any others — which is what the header's MIXED and MASKING rows already say, and what keeps a stamp from hiding behind backticks. What was broken is the sentence telling the author what to do.

The card named three arms; this PR takes the third and pins why

arm	verdict
teach the declaration reader the fence	⛔ refused — a third semantic for a quoted span (text for substitution, declaration for the contract). The rule above is worth what it is because it has exactly one.
exempt fenced content from the MIXED scan	⛔ refused — the one direction this file may not take, for the reason the MIXED and MASKING rows already give.
keep the behaviour, fix the text	⭐ taken, and the header section says so, so the next reader does not reopen it.

⭐ Neither refused arm serves the body that was filed. A pasted git log line carries its stamp BARE, so no arm reaches it; wrapping that stamp in {{WAS:…}} to satisfy one would print the token inside the fence and publish a quotation the quoted command never emitted.

⛔ A remedy is worth what FOLLOWING it does — the patch round

The first cut of this fix named only half the route: 「the same declaration OUTSIDE the quotation」. The review of record measured what happens next, and it was not good enough: an author who did exactly that — declared the reading in the prose, pasted the quoted line back unchanged — was refused [mixed] a second time, and that second refusal carried the OLD circular text 「Declare it with {{WAS:…}}」 while that declaration was already standing in the prose. quotedSpanRemedy returned null as soon as one occurrence sat outside a span, so the ordinary remedy fired. The circle had moved one step, not closed — the rider's (e) shape, reached by the fix for it.

So every occurrence of the digits is now classified, and only the fourth kind leaves this remedy to the ordinary one:

the occurrence	reading
inside a {{WAS:…}} that is itself quoted	a PICTURE of a declaration, not one
inside a quotation with no opener round it	digits, plainly
inside a {{WAS:…}} TOKEN outside every quotation	a real declaration, and it READS
anywhere else	a loose stamp in prose — the ordinary remedy, unchanged

And the route names both halves, always: declare the reading in the prose and paste the quoted line WITHOUT its stamp, or quote the placeholder form instead of digits. ⛔ A quotation that KEEPS the digits is still a bare stamp there. Where the declaration already reads in the prose, the refusal says so and names the quoted occurrence as the one thing left, rather than asking for the declaration again.

The three follow-ups ridden on this card (rider 5770506431)

• (c) the quoted-value gate was body-wide while its comment described a per-value rule. Now per value — and the refused values carry the stamps inside them, because the declared walk reads the RENDERED body.
• (c) positionsTaken was a Set, so two subscript lines carrying the same stamp collapsed to one row. Now a multiset whose credits exist only so the declared walk declines a position the bare scan already took.
• (f) hit.stamp === now compared at the minute grain only, so a declaration of the act's OWN clock at the seconds grain was refused while H56 files nothing. Now minute containment through stampSpan — ⛔ the minute, never H56_STAMP_TOLERANCE_MIN.
• (e) the mixed remedy handing back the declared spelling is the card's own defect, fixed above and then fixed properly in the patch round. Its second clause — 「on a position line carrying two stamps, following it lands on positional and then positional-declared」 — did not reproduce as stated; the measured chain is mixed, mixed → declare one → positional → declare the other → accepted.

Evidence

The chain, pinned end to end, because that is the thing the first cut got wrong:

step	body	verdict	what its text says next
1	the filed repro — token + declaration inside the fence	mixed	declare in the PROSE and paste the line without its stamp
2	declared in the prose, line pasted unchanged (bare or token-wrapped)	mixed	the declaration ALREADY reads — ⛔ not asked for again; take the digits out
3	declared in the prose, fence without the stamp	ACCEPTED	—

⛔ No widening, measured across six body shapes (the review's own probe, re-run on the final head against the base 4fba5036f): every one of the six verdicts is identical on base and head — mixed, mixed, mixed, ACCEPTED, mixed, positional. Only the remedy TEXTS moved. The bare-stamp-in-a-fence control is refused exactly as before.

Reverse verification (scripts/ablation-replace.mjs, anchor declared to hit once, write and restore verified against the disk): nulling the prose-declared classification — the patch round's own mechanism — turned 5 of 584 cases red, precisely the step-2 pins, while step 3 and the controls stayed green. Restore proved by blob, not by an exit code: 226f7a6cd1141efeeb42d1aec964f5cae123fbb0 before and after, git diff HEAD empty, self-test back to 584 green.

Self-test: 584 cases across 19 batteries, offline. Battery floors raised with the cases (the quoting spelling 52 → 67, the two positions 17 → 24), ⛔ never lowered.

Gates run locally, at the final head e976b048e

Derived with node scripts/pm/dispatch-gates.mjs --repo objectstack-ai/objectstack --commands (no paths) and reconciled with --ran: 30 derived, 30 run, 0 NOT-MEASURED, 0 UNRUN, every one recorded as command :: exit code captured before any pipe. Includes pnpm check:pm-post-stamped (584 cases), pnpm check:nul-bytes, pnpm check:pm-dispatch-gates (724s on this box).

Owed beyond the derivation: scripts/pm/close-cards.mjs --self-test exit 0 (102 cases) and scripts/pm/check-half-states.mjs --self-test exit 0 (5160 cases) — both import from this file.

eslint, narrowed and declared: pnpm exec eslint scripts/pm/post-stamped.mjs --no-inline-config --format json → exit 0, 1 file linted (counted from the JSON), 0 errors, 0 warnings. The narrowing is a measurement: the population is read from eslint.config.mjs itself, which states this repo runs one config that 「never enables type-aware linting (no parserOptions.project, no typed @typescript-eslint rules) for ANY file」 — so this diff cannot move the verdict on any file it does not touch. The repo-wide pnpm lint belongs to CI. Control-byte self-scan beyond the gate: grep -naP over the changed file, no hits.

Line budget

Net +209 (263 added / 54 removed, one file) against the dispatch's suggested ≤ +80 — declared, not quiet. Roughly +49 header (the decision pin plus the patch round's 「both halves」 paragraph), +47 the twenty-three self-test cases and their fixtures, the remainder the occurrence classifier and the two new readers with their doc comments. No ceiling moved and no ratchet involved: scripts/pm/** carries none, and both battery floors moved UP.

Changeset

skip-changeset: scripts/pm/** publishes nothing. Measured — the repo root package is private: true with no files[], and no non-private package in the tree declares a files[] entry that could reach scripts/.

Acceptance notes

Two observations met on the way, neither filed (both below the filing bar):

• The positional-declared refusal text says the declaration 「renders THERE as the bare stamp」. For an opener left VERBATIM inside a quotation at one of the two positions that sentence is imprecise, while the refusal itself is correct, because H56 reads digits off the stored line either way. Carrier: the next PR in this refusal family.
• h56StampedReadings returns no line index, which is why the positional-declared de-duplication has to be a multiset over position-name plus stamp rather than a key on the line. The reader lives in check-half-states.mjs, outside this card's declared file surface, so it was not touched.

维护者速读(草稿)

改了什么 — post-stamped 拒绝理由里的「怎么办」那一句。以前它把作者已经写好的那条声明原样念回去;第一版补丁只说了半句「把声明移到引用块外面」,复审实测发现照做之后还会再被拒一次,而那次拒绝又把刚写进正文的声明念了回去——圈只是挪了一步。现在这句话说全了:数字必须离开引用块(正文里声明 + 粘贴的那行去掉时间戳,或改用占位符);已经在正文声明过的,拒绝会说「那条声明是有效的,别再写一遍」,只指出引用块里还剩的数字。顺带落了同一族的三个小修。

为什么改 — 卡片实测三次:按提示照做等于什么都没做。拒绝本身是对的(引用块里的数字仍是板上的数字),错的是那句提示。

风险与代价(含回滚) — 拒绝面一个字节都没变宽:复审的六种形态在 base 与本分支上判决完全相同,只有文字变了。消融实验证明新用例真的会红。回滚成本 = revert 单文件单 PR。净增 209 行(建议上限 80),超出部分是 header 里钉决策与「两个半句」的段落,以及 23 条自测用例。

席位意见 —— 技能席 1(session_01Wnstp2kTth7sGXfr8fXypc)已按 GitHub 与拉取的 head e976b048e 复核两轮。第 0 轮记录 FAIL 5774680155:新补救文案指的路本身走不通——作者照做(散文里声明、围栏里保留数字)仍被拒,且拒绝文案回到旧循环句;补丁轮 1 三件欠项全闭合,本席用同一套六种正文形态在 base 与 head 上量过全文:每一种被拒形态的文案都写明「散文里声明 + 引用块里的行去掉戳(或引占位符)」,散文已声明的形态改为点名引用块里那一处、⛔ 不再叫作者重打声明,六种裁决 base/head 逐一相同(无放宽);链式用例 STEP 1→2→3 钉住,floor 60→67。本席在独立 worktree 复跑自测 584/19、两个引入方自测(5160、102)、nul-bytes、eslint 均 exit 0;check-governed-merges --pr 19707 读不受管。复核记录 PASS 5775158312(席内 fable),--pair 0,ACCEPT 5775160838 在卡上;开发的开放问题(是否教声明读者识别围栏)本席在车道内判 A——保留拒绝、只改文案;B 会推翻 #18543 的钉子,您若想要,是另一张卡。全绿即由本席按普通队列入队。

你要做的 — 确认一件事:卡片给了三个方案,本 PR 选了第三个(保留行为、修提示),并在 header 里写明另外两个为什么不选。三选一的判断权在维护者;如果希望改成「围栏里的声明算声明」,那是另一张卡,且要动 #18543 钉下的决定。

---

🤖 Generated with Claude Code

https://claude.ai/code/session_01Wnstp2kTth7sGXfr8fXypc

---

Generated by Claude Code

[huangyiirene]

Contract review

Served-tier: CONTRACT_REVIEW_TIER
Head-sha: 73185026ac096e32255d544935a6a35d27106656

① Derived judgments

Rendered in-seat by the skills seat 1 session at the served tier the maintainer named on this date (the fable tier word at get_session → external_metadata.last_served_model; ruling record 5771798588; the constant on origin/main names it since PR #19684). The contract is the card's measured refusal (a a WAS declaration declared inside a fenced block beside the act-clock token is refused mixed with a remedy prescribing that same declaration), the lane's grading 5753148560 (the three arms; 「the dev decides and pins」) and the seat's rider 5770506431 (the #18995 record's three follow-ups in the same file).

• (a) The arm taken — accepted, with the argument pinned. The dispatch's Zone 1 read the fix as 「the two readers take the same reading」; the dev took the card's third arm instead (the refusal stays, the remedy changes) and refused the other two in the file's header with the four axes: a a WAS declaration inside a quotation is rendered as TEXT by the quoting contract, so reading it as a declaration would give a quoted span a second semantic; exempting the fence from the bare scan is the one direction the MIXED / MASKING rows forbid; and neither arm serves the filed body, because a pasted git log line carries its stamp BARE and wrapping it would publish a quotation the command never emitted. The grading delegated the choice to the dev; the argument holds against the file's own header; the deviation from Zone 1 is declared, not silent. The dev's open question (A: what landed · B: teach the reader the fence) is graded A in-lane: B reverses the pm(post-stamped): {{NOW}} is substituted inside a QUOTATION of the token, so a seat cannot quote the tool's own diagnostic through the tool — measured as a false quotation published on #14251 #18543 pins and is its own card if the maintainer wants it — ⛔ not a decision-box item.
• (b) The rider — three of four clauses delivered and pinned, one measured not reproducing. (c) the body-wide quotedValueProblems === 0 gate is now per value (refusedValues, the payload and every stamp inside it; case 「a typo elsewhere no longer hides the row at a position」) and positionsTaken is a multiset (takeCredit; case 「two subscript lines carrying the SAME declared stamp are TWO rows」, bare control unchanged); (f) hit.stamp === now is now minute containment through stampSpan (readingIsThisMinute; the seconds-grain own-clock case accepted, the minute BEFORE still refused, ⛔ never H56_STAMP_TOLERANCE_MIN); (e) first clause is the card's defect; the second clause's chain was measured on the base as [mixed, mixed] → [positional] → accepted, not positional → positional-declared — reported, not papered over; accepted as measured.
• (c) Diff and hygiene — right. One file, +188 / −54, three commits (two steps + the origin/main merge at 4fba5036f, the merge base), blob 0b582cc79 at the head; SELF_TEST_BATTERIES floors 52 → 60 and 17 → 24, never lowered; the header gains a dated section; trailers model-free per check:commit-card-trailers (the harness reminder yields to the repo file, os-dev.md). Net +134 against Zone 3's optional ≤ +80 — +35 header, +29 cases, the rest two readers with doc comments; declared, accepted. The 维护者速读 on a non-governed PR is harmless.
• (d) ⛔ THE FINDING — the remedy names a route that does not post, measured by this seat on the head, not the report. The seat imported stampRefusals from the base (4fba5036f) and from the head and ran six body shapes (scratchpad/seat/probe-19707.mjs). The filed repro (the act-clock token + a a WAS declaration inside a fence) is refused mixed on both, and the head's remedy now ends 「The route that works is the same declaration OUTSIDE the quotation — a WAS declaration in the prose beside it」. An author who follows it — declares the reading in the prose and leaves the fenced line as pasted, with the token or with bare digits — is refused mixed again on the head, and that second refusal carries the OLD circular text 「Declare it with a WAS declaration if it is a quoted reading」 while that declaration already stands in the prose: quotedSpanRemedy returns null there (one occurrence, the prose declaration, is outside the span) and the ordinary remedy fires. The only shape that posts is the one whose fence carries NO digits (the self-test's 「the body that takes that route POSTS」 case is exactly that, and so was the card's own successful post) — and no remedy on the head says so. The base's dropped clause did (「Move the stamp out of the quotation to declare it」). The circle the card measured is not closed; it moved one step, which is the rider's (e) shape: a refusal prescribing what is already on the page.
• (e) Gates — measured by this seat on a clean worktree at 73185026a after pnpm install --frozen-lockfile --offline. check:pm-post-stamped 577 cases / 19 batteries, check-half-states.mjs --self-test 5160, close-cards.mjs --self-test 102, check:nul-bytes, check-self-test-wired, check-scripts-symbol-anchors — all exit 0; eslint over the file 1 judged, 0 / 0; no raw control byte; check-governed-merges.mjs --pr 19707 exit 0 — NOT governed, 0 of 1 path on the register, 242 lines. The dev's 30-family derivation reconciled --ran 30 / 30 / 0 NOT-MEASURED, the 11-minute check:pm-dispatch-gates run twice (pre-merge and merged head), and the ablation (the mixed route selection nulled ⇒ 6 of 577 red, blob restored 0b582cc79) read as reported. CI at this head: 31 latest-per-name check runs, Lint & Repo Gates in progress at the seat's read, the rest success or skipped.

② Semver level

None — no release. scripts/pm/** is in no package's files[]; skip-changeset is the correct carrier, written through label-write.mjs with read-back; size/m is the labeler's.

③ Boundary flags

• Not governed — ordinary queue landing by the seat on a PASS record, --pair 0 and all checks green; ⛔ not before the patch round below.
• Report 5774603526 on the card parses (os-dev-report first line; the JSON re-parses from the stored comment); mcp_calls 0; three REST writes plus four pushes as budgeted; ⛔ no body PATCH by the dev.
• Out of scope, noted by the dev, not filed: the positional-declared wording 「renders THERE as the bare stamp」 for a verbatim opener at a position (a nit); h56StampedReadings returning no line index (a shape observation in check-half-states.mjs).

Must change before this record can read PASS (one round, this file only): (1) the quoted-span remedy tail says the DIGITS leave the quotation — the reading is declared in the prose beside it and the quoted line is pasted WITHOUT its stamp (or quotes the placeholder form); a quotation that keeps the digits is still a bare stamp there; (2) the shape 「the value declared in the prose AND the same digits standing inside a quotation, bare or token-wrapped」 gets a remedy that names the quoted occurrence and says to take the digits out — ⛔ never 「Declare it with a WAS declaration」, which is already on the page; (3) both pinned: the chain that FOLLOWS each remedy from the filed repro ends ACCEPTED, every step's text naming the next step, plus the prose-declared-and-quoted shape's remedy; floors up. Everything else in the diff stands.

Implemented-by: claude/issue-19319-post-stamped-fenced-declared-stamp
Reviewed-by: session_01Wnstp2kTth7sGXfr8fXypc

VERDICT: FAIL

---

Generated by Claude Code

[huangyiirene]

Contract review

Served-tier: CONTRACT_REVIEW_TIER
Head-sha: e976b048e3279056569900ba743c129f5d4e8f0c

① Derived judgments

Rendered in-seat by the skills seat 1 session at the served tier the maintainer named on this date (the fable tier word at get_session → external_metadata.last_served_model; ruling record 5771798588; the constant on origin/main names it since PR #19684). Patch round 1 after the FAIL of record 5774680155 (head 73185026a), which owed three things: (1) the quoted-span remedy says the DIGITS leave the quotation; (2) the shape 「declared in the prose AND the same digits inside a quotation」 gets a remedy naming the quoted occurrence, never the declaration already on the page; (3) both pinned as a chain from the filed repro to a body that posts. The contract is unchanged (the card's third arm with its four-axis pin; the rider's (c) / (f); (e)'s second clause measured not reproducing — all accepted in the FAIL record and untouched here).

• (a) The round is the three owed items and nothing else — measured. git diff 73185026a e976b048e -- scripts/pm/post-stamped.mjs is +102 / −27: the occurrence classifier in quotedSpanRemedy (quotedDeclared / quotedBare / proseDeclared / loose), the three remedy arms, the mixed opener's third arm, a header paragraph on why the route is BOTH halves, the chain cases, and the floor. The merge of origin/main (a251aaa19, the merge base) carries none of the PR's path. PR total vs origin/main: one file, +263 / −54; blob 226f7a6cd114 at the head.
• (b) The finding is closed — measured by this seat with the same six shapes, full remedy texts (scratchpad/seat/probe-19707-full.mjs). The filed repro's remedy now reads 「The DIGITS are what has to leave the quotation: declare the reading in the PROSE beside it … AND paste the quoted line WITHOUT its stamp — or, if the quotation is an EXAMPLE, quote the placeholder form」; the half-done body (declared in the prose, the fenced line as pasted, bare or token-wrapped) is still refused mixed and its text now reads 「This reading is ALREADY declared in the prose, and that declaration reads — ⛔ re-typing it changes nothing. What is left is the same digits / the declaration-shaped text standing inside a quotation … keep the declaration where it is and paste the quoted line WITHOUT its stamp」; the bare-in-fence control and the backtick-span positional case carry the same both-halves tail. No shape's text prescribes 「Declare it with …」 any more. The body that did both halves posts.
• (c) No widening — measured. The six verdicts are identical on the base (4fba5036f) and on this head (mixed ×4, ACCEPTED ×1, positional ×1); only the remedy texts moved. The refusal stays, as the FAIL record required.
• (d) Pins — a chain, floors up. STEP 1 (the repro's remedy names both halves) → STEP 2 (declaring in the prose while pasting the line unchanged is still refused, its text names the quoted occurrence and not the present declaration; the token-wrapped variant lands on the same remedy) → STEP 3 (the body that did both halves POSTS), plus the loose-occurrence control keeping the ordinary remedy; 「the quoting spelling」 60 → 67, 「the two positions」 24 unchanged; 584 cases across 19 batteries (577 at the reviewed head, 562 on the base). The dev's ablation on the new route (proseDeclared += 1 → return null ⇒ 5 of 584 red — the step-2 pins — STEP 3 and every control green; blob restored 226f7a6cd114) reads as reported. The dev's lesson is recorded in the file: the first cut's 「POSTS」 case proved a body posts, never that FOLLOWING the remedy reaches it.
• (e) Gates — measured by this seat on a clean worktree at e976b048e. check:pm-post-stamped 584 / 19, check-half-states.mjs --self-test 5160, close-cards.mjs --self-test 102, check:nul-bytes, check-self-test-wired, check-scripts-symbol-anchors — all exit 0; eslint over the file 1 judged, 0 / 0; no raw control byte; check-governed-merges.mjs --pr 19707 exit 0 — NOT governed, 0 of 1 path, 317 lines. The dev's 30-family derivation reconciled --ran 30 / 30 / 0 NOT-MEASURED at this head and the 1906-case check:pm-dispatch-gates (724 s) read as reported. CI at this head: 31 latest-per-name check runs, Lint & Repo Gates in progress at the seat's read, the rest success or skipped.
• (f) Line budget. Net +209 against Zone 3's optional ≤ +80 (the classifier and its arms, the header paragraph, nine chain cases) — declared, accepted: the chain is what the FAIL record asked for.

② Semver level

None — no release. scripts/pm/** is in no package's files[]; skip-changeset is the correct carrier (written through label-write.mjs with read-back in round 0); size/m is the labeler's.

③ Boundary flags

• Not governed — ordinary queue landing by the seat on all green and --pair 0, after the body PATCH below.
• Write pacing honoured by the dev: the budget read 40 / 40 before its one write; it waited in-turn for the instant the tool named and re-read 39 / 40 before posting — ⛔ no bare-curl workaround.
• The seat's writes on this PR: this record; one body PATCH replacing round 0's body with the dev's pr_body_replacement for this head (carried in report 5774998402, read back byte-identical to its file; 「席位意见」 filled by the seat) — announced here; the dev made ⛔ no body PATCH in either round.
• Report 5774998402 on the card parses (os-dev-report first line, one footer); mcp_calls 0; one REST write this round plus two pushes, as budgeted; the worktree kept at the branch head.
• Out of scope, unchanged from round 0: the positional-declared wording nit; h56StampedReadings returning no line index.

Implemented-by: claude/issue-19319-post-stamped-fenced-declared-stamp
Reviewed-by: session_01Wnstp2kTth7sGXfr8fXypc

VERDICT: PASS

---

Generated by Claude Code